13 Reasons Why is a book by Jay Asher adapted for the TV screen by Netflix. The story follows teenager Clay Jensen, in his quest to uncover the story behind his classmate and crush, Hannah, and her decision to end her life.
Do I think 13 Reasons Why is a
good series? I do. What was it like watching it? It was hard and disturbing from
beginning to end. Why did I do it? Because I felt it was my duty as a teacher,
mother and responsible adult.
As a teacher to teenagers I've
been often asked for help or I have willingly offered help when recognizing clear symptoms of suffering. I
don't expect a TV show, neither as good as this one, may help solve or face all
the serious and tragic issues, 13 Reasons Why deals with, but I’m sure the 13
hours I spent watching it and thinking about why some of my students were so
interested in it have been well spent, as shocking as my watching was.
Suicide may be not as popular as
it is in the US here in Italy but the number of cases is increasing. Bullying
is an increasingly worrying phenomenon made even worse by the use of the web.
How can we fight monsters like those?
I have no easy answer, only lots
of questions and doubts. But one thing is clear to me: our young people live in
a more sterile and hostile enivronment, tougher than the one we had to cope
with at their age, they need help and we must be there for them.
The reasons why reality is so hard are not the TV series depticting it
It is not easy to cope with
teenagers, not easy at all. You need infinite patience, you must brace yourself and be
ready to being deluded and disappointed more often than rewarded. However,
responsible adults should really try to understand the reasons why they are so
interested in such terrible stories depicted in all their gritty details – many
of my male students love Gomorrah and Narcos,
for instance - then talk with them, without shying away
because the issues proposed are tough, embarassing or painful.
Sometimes I get the impression
they are just trying to build their armour, lance and shield to
fight the monsters they have to face in the real world every day by watching or
reading such graphic, gritty stuff.
Reactions to the series
I’ve read furious comments of
parents who refuse to watch the series, blame Netflix for sensationalizing and
romanticizing suicide. I’ve read of schools that are divulging notes to both parents
and teachers suggesting to the first to prevent their children from watching the series and prohibiting the latter to
discuss the series with their students in their classes. I’ve also read
comments and suggestions by worried experts - a couple of which I have linked at the bottom
of this post,- as well as positive reviews by critics. When was the last time a book or a series
arose so much ado? The
Catcher in the Rye? On
The Road? Rebel without a
Cause? A Clockwork
Orange? The Hunger Games? Fifty Shades of Grey?
My reasons why
I heard of the series from my
students, they wrote about its release on Netlix in the web magazine,
which is our school project for this year. When I read what it was about I
freezed. But my personal policy doesn’t
include blind censorship and tend to
always attempt to discover more and understand.
In my experience to strongly criticize what teens are apparently
sincerely curious about or interested in just makes you someone they can’t
trust or believe in. To banish topics from your classes or avoid answering their embarassing or even
foolish questions makes you someone useless to their eyes. So when I heard they
were going to watch the series to review it for their web magazine, I thought, I’ll watch it too and discuss it
with them, if necessary.
I didn’t expect it would either be such a
global controversial matter neither that it would be that hard to me to
watch. I thought of my students watching
it all the way through with great
anxiety. I really hope our school is not
such hell to our students. I really hope we have no Hannah, no Bryce nor Justin, no
Jessica nor Alex and wished we had more Clay–like or Tony-like guys. But I fear
we have all of them hidden among the smiling or concerned teens we meet every
day. I really prayed I never happened to be, by any
chance, like Mr Porter in the final
episode. I prayed I never had to face as much as Hannah's parents.
Conclusions
I am convinced this show can be both
helpful as harmful. Much depends on who watches it and how they
may get its harsh issues, especially if
they are the most fragile among our
young people.
As we well know, to banish or
prohibit something doesn’t work miracles with young adults. That just make them
more willing to dare and to overcome limits. Hormones and psychological turmoil
make them naturally prone to disobey and
break rules. Parents and teachers must know that.
That’s why I think they should
watch the show and, if they discover
their children or students have seen it despite all their efforts to avoid
that, they should be ready to face the ugly truth and prepare themselves to
give those young people, if not 13, at
least a few reasons why they should always choose life over death, love over hate,
sympathy over aggressiveness, tolerance over prejudice.
Useful reads to discuss the series
I thought this was interesting: http://nymag.com/thecut/2017/05/teenagers-explain-what-adults-dont-get-about-13-reasons-why.html
ReplyDeleteI'm reading it with my elder niece. We haven't watched the tv show.
Thank you for the link, Servetus. I didn't read the book, I heard there are some differences, as usual. I hope you and your niece will have a good chat on the issues the story deals with.
ReplyDelete